DIY Maven

DIY Maven

3902 posts

Although I'm a writer by education and profession, I have a not-so-secret DIY and craft (of almost any kind) addiction. I'm the… read more

Comments - What's the Best Bottle Cutter on the Market? We Find Out

Melissa on Jan 05, 2018:

Thank you so much for this article!! I have the G2 and am ready to move onto greener pastures. I'm going to get the Ephrem cutter. Thank you!

HEATHER on Aug 10, 2017:

i bought an Ephrems and have spent all day with out success. i used the candle and ice cold water as i didnt have ice cubes. no luck, the bottles didnt even seperate. i tried puttong the bottles in the deep freeze to get them cold but no luck. so the trick must be in the ice cube? i also tried the cold water...boiling water baths. no luck!! feeling frustrated

Bev on May 31, 2017:

I want to just cut the bottoms off of wine bottles or smaller sized bottles like a Worcestershire bottle. I want not more than an inch of the bottom. Are any of these cutters capable of that?
Thank you in advance for your reply.

Janice on May 04, 2017:

Thank you for all the detailed information. I have been looking at some of the square bottles (mostly from Bourbon makers) and thinking that those bottles could be very interesting vases or light fixtures. I have never cut a bottle before and will probably purchase your A+grade Ephrem's because of the angle/slope on some of the bottles I like best. Thanks again!!

Nick Jager on Apr 18, 2017:

I've reviewed a few of the same bottle cutters myself and would agree with all the grades that you handed out. Although I thought you were being generous with the 'D' for the g2. It reminded me of when Tommy Boy got excited and claimed that he 'passed!'. Great round-up of all the different bottle cutters available.

Cynthia on Mar 10, 2016:

I am looking to cut crystal decanters. Would Creator's or Ephrem's work on lead crystal?

John Galt on Mar 08, 2016:

Kudos on the head to head match-up. I have Ephram's cutter and love it. It gives consistent and even score lines (both in depth and matching the beginning and ending).

I have been cutting bottles for about two years. While scoring of the bottle is important, proper stressing of the score line is also important.

I used to be very impatient and try to get the bottle cut in two or three passes on the candle. And my success rate was about 50% (terrible).

I eventually realized that successful stressing requires patience. I didn't need to overly heat the score line. I needed to evenly apply small amounts of heat, then cool. But do it over more rounds of heating and cooling.

Now I take my time and do many passes with heating and cooling. While it may take longer, it insures that the stressing is more likely to follow the score line.

Another benefit is that the eventual cut line is very even, and, in my experience, not sharp or dangerous. Because of this, it also requires less sanding.

Once I learned some patience, my success rate has gone to about 99%.

RG on Feb 21, 2016:

Hey! THANKS for this!!! This was exactly the comparison test I was hoping someone had done. Really appreciate it.

Jennifer on Nov 17, 2015:

Murrays bottle cutting technique was great. I went back to review video and the video is private now. I has hoping he'd be willing to repost one that isn't private. I bought the items needed and have done bottles I wanted to try to cut. Thanks!

natasha on Sep 28, 2015:

Hi are you able to review the Luca and C and C, both look simillar, cant decide between those and the Ephram. Got the g2, and as predicted, 1 out of 10 bottles were barely usable, more the amber than green for some reason green seams more brittle. 

Thanks for your reviews, really helpful, although wish i'd seen them after spending 2 hours assembling the g2!!

Andee on Aug 26, 2015:

I`m truly amazed by the C&C Bottle Cutter. Works like a dream.

Yet would be happy to try the other bottle cutters as well :)

Steve on Aug 06, 2015:

Please send me the link for that video on the separation technique you,ve been using.



Murray on Jul 20, 2015:

I don't mean to pull this thread off on a tangent but I thought I would share what I came up with as the best process for cutting glass bottles. It gives me a way to achieve perfect straight cuts with perfect yoeld 100% of the time. It uses no boiling water, no flames, torches, or combustible gases or liquids.  I put together a video and posted the link below. Just one disclaimer:  I used Creator's Bottle Cutter in the video because it has worked best for me in my work. If you are tired of reading about bottle scoring devices you can skip the first 3 mins of the video.

Cheers, Murray

DIY Maven on Jul 20, 2015:

@Kris--I haven't seen a comprehensive review of the Luca yet. If they'd send me one, I'd gladly add my findings to this post. ;) Think they read these comments??

@Els--I'd never heard of the Kent before reading your comment. They certainly DO look alike, but unless I had one in my hands, I couldn't comment on its performance in comparison to Ephram's. As far as manufacture, Ephram's in made in the U.S., Kent is made in China. 

Els on Jul 19, 2015:


Is there any different between the Kent and the Ephrem bottle cutter. On the internet, they look the same?

Carol on Jul 03, 2015:

You can buy anything on ebay!  I think most sellers ship international but be sure to check price.  I was warned not to do beer bottles because it is a different type of glass - because of heat processing.  I just recently tried a few and had 50-50 luck with a clean cut and getting cracks up the bottle.  I was using the G2 and hot water/ice water dipping.  

els on Jul 03, 2015:

Is it possible to cut beer bottles or bottles of 33 cl (I think of the Savanna-bottles, a South African primium cider) with the Ephrem's bottle cutter? 

And can i buy the cutter in Belgium?


Ray on Jun 27, 2015:

Carol. The Creator's Bottle Neck Cutter is your answer.

Carol on Jun 27, 2015:

I have been using the G2 and have done around 200 wine bottles for lanterns.  It is wearing out and I am debating what kind to get now.  I have a friend that wants shot glasses made by cutting beer bottles at the neck.  None of these appear to be friendly to cutting at the narrow section the bottle.  Do you have any suggestions??

Ray Nicholas on Apr 06, 2015:

Good Day DIY Maven. We listen to our customers and we respond. Our separating rings are now more pliable. We went with a lower durometer. (35A). A lot of people try to stretch the ring and then put it on the bottle. That is not so easy. If you roll the rings down the bottle, they go on very easily. Thank you for your in-depth reviews. We always strive to make the best better. Your friend,  Ray Nicholas   President-Creator's Stained Glass

DIY Maven on Apr 01, 2015:

Murray, I didn't even think of the tapered bottle scenario. With that in mind, I'm going to lower my grade to a "C." Thanks for the input!

Murray on Mar 31, 2015:

In addition to the issues you have pointed out with the Kinkajou on bottles with square and oval corners, I have never been able to make a straight score on tapered bottles. A large % of wine bottles have slight to moderate tapers. The kinkajou rollers are flat and they always try to stay flat against the bottle which means as you rotate it tends to spiral. I work with very expensive bottles and have zero tolerance for error. I shelved the kinajou long ago. 

DIY Maven on Mar 31, 2015:

You are very welcome, Milly!

Milly on Mar 31, 2015:

Thank you for this great review. I had difficulty choosing between Kinkajou a Ephrims. But now I now. Thank you so much from South Africa.

DIY Maven on Mar 30, 2015:

Hello everybody!! I've updated the Best Bottle Cutter Review to include The Kinkajou Bottle Cutter. Scroll down to the bottom of the post for pics and opinions. 

Hope it helps in your decision-making, and thanks for all the comments!

DIY Maven

Add Your Comment!

(2000 character limit)