Love where you live. Sign up for our newsletter

Decor Disputes: Pantone v. Sherwin-Williams Color of the Year Smackdown!

by on Dec 5, 2014

Pantone We knew this was coming…. Pantone announced its color of the year just days after Sherwin-Williams unveiled their pick. We explored S-W’s choice, Coral Reef, earlier this week that included images that proved it lived up to its descriptors “versatile, carefree, and cheerful.” Now enter into the ring Pantone’s pick: Marsala. It’s described by Pantone as earthy, nurturing, fulfilling, and hearty, just to name a few adjectives. Does it live up to them? This time, I’ll let you decide. Here are a couple of images of the color in action: 

"White fabric chair and table with books."Sourceable

A red door to a home is opened up.Houzz

And to refresh your memory regarding S-W’s pick, here’s the Coral Reef:

A yellow double chair in front of a pink rectangle painted on the wall.Vintage Revivals

A pink table with a television on it in a living room with a grey couch with one blue and one pink pillow on it.Classy Clutter

So, what do you think? Who wins the heavy weight, Color of the Year match this go-around? Pantone or Sherwin Williams?? 

10 Comments

  1. Coral Reef!!!  Coral has always been my very favorite color for clothing and home decor.

  2. Though Marsala is rich, deep and earthy, Coral is the fresh, bright and more versital color we need in a dark year!

  3. Marsala!! I prefer the darker more earthy colors. I think Marsala will be a color you can leave on the wall longer than the more trendy Coral Reef. Marsala won’t look dated as quickly as Coral Reef.

  4. For decor, I don’t care for either one of them.  They both seem like serious throwbacks to decor trends I didn’t like the first time.  Marsala looks like the burgundy-ish mauve of the late 80s/early 90s (think florals with hunter green backgrounds.)  Coral reef reminds me of the 80s pastel “southwest” decor or something out of a Florida vacation condo.

    Of the two colors, I like Marsala better. The only orange colors I like are deep, rich ones–terracotta & burnt orange.

    Marsala looks like an excellent color for lipstick, nail polish, and clothing for either men or women.  I just can’t visualize it in my house without having 80s/90s flashbacks.

  5. They both are terrible. Marsala is exactly the mud color of dried blood, and I agree that Coral Reef looks like somthing out of Florida or the southwest.

    Blecccchhhhh!

  6. I do think they both look like retro colors. If I had to pick, I’d go with Coral Reef. Now next year are we going to have Harvest Gold and Avocado Green??